Skip to main content

Health Care is not Like Buying a Car

Rant for the Day:

I prefer buying a car by comparison shopping and then selecting the dealer who gives me the best price. But a classic dealer tactic is high-pressure negotiation in which they push the buy-now special to keep me from comparing prices and included accessories elsewhere. How frustrating to buy a car and then find your neighbor bought the same car from the same dealer the next day for $500 less. Dealer invoices don't help, because they don't show dealer incentives and rebates. Neither do they show the influence of the bank that actually owns the dealer's stock.

If you think that buying a car is complicated, consider buying healthcare.

Despite claims to the contrary, IMHO, you can't reliably comparison shop hospitals and doctors. You may put off buying a car for a week while you compare prices, but that emergency bypass is not likely to wait. Moreover, surgeons and hospitals don't have the brand-name consistency of Ford or Toyota. I've yet to see a hospital procedure that came with a sticker price.

Looking over the hospital bills for my sister-in-law, I notice that the hospitals billed insurance for more than a half-million dollars, but the private insurance "negotiated" the price down to about $80K: Obviously, a disconnect in what the services are deemed to be worth even more spectacular than car prices. After the negotiation, I don't deny that money was still made by both organizations, but I sincerely don't believe (See SCOTUS recent decision on sincere beliefs) that much of that money went to doctors and nurses.

Making huge profits on healthcare has evolved from being a dysfunctional nuisance into a diseased system. Why can't we have a sanity? Because corporations who benefit from the current system like to stir up fear and resentment like "you can't see your own doctor" or "someone undeserving might get medical care."

If you don't want to pay for another person's hospital visit because you don't approve of that person, then #1. You don't understand the way insurance works either, and #2. Shouldn't you worry that others with more influence might likewise disapprove of you?

Some physicians have come out in favor of a single payer plan. I agree. It is a sensible way to control costs, something the other schemes are incapable of doing. It doesn't encourage insurers to profit by denying me coverage, but then I'm distrustful of a profit motive for healthcare when it is virtually impossible  to comparison shop. Besides, it makes actuarial sense to require that every one is covered and everyone pays.

On the downside for politicians, a single payer system eliminates a large source of campaign funds from private insurers and other special interest, and perhaps that best explains the fiery rhetoric in Congress against any such a plan.

I don't mind if a single-payer plan is bare-bones (excuse the pun) and allows those who wish to add "premium" coverage from private insurers:that's pretty much how Medicare works now.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

10,000 FREE eBOOKS

Why give away 10,000+ ebooks?  Simple Economics: To advertise ONE $3.99 eBOOK and get 667 people to click on the ad to read the book description and perhaps some sample pages would cost me between $467 and $670 with no guarantee of any immediate purchase or a sale within a month. If as many as the optimal 10% actually bought the book after clicking on the ad, I might make $100 or less. If I'm lucky, I would lose at least $367 on books sold to perhaps 70 people. I have 15 books in my catalog. Then it would cost me between $7000 and $10,000 to advertise them all with no guarantee that any of them would be sold or read. On the other hand,  If I persuade just 667 people on social media to download all 15 books in my fiction catalog when I offer them free during the JULY Summer Sale at Smashwords, then rather than getting them to read a short blurb describing the book, I’ve actually placed each book into the hands of a possible reader at no cost to myself or the reader. A ...

Things I Don't Understand

Some uses for Classifications, Definitions, Refining definitions, and Re-purposing words. On the one hand: Why do we drive on a parkway, and park on a driveway? Shouldn't hot water heaters be called cold water heaters? If the water is already hot, why heat it? Shouldn't there be another word that sounds like the word homonym but means something different or is spelled differently? See #3. Homonym apparently isn't precise enough to distinguish all possible cases. Therefore, we refine the concept with homophones, homographs, heteronyms, heterophones, heterographs, capitonyms . . . I'm not making these word up* . Even though I have difficulty remembering the distinctions among these more precise categories , I understand that for linguists, the ability to distinguish among various types of homonyms could be useful. For example, a capitonym changes its meaning or pronunciation when capitalized. For example furniture polish is not pronounced like Polish ...

Coronavirus: Flatten the Curve, Delay the Onset

Coronavirus: Spread Out the Cases to Flatten the Curve and Delay the Onset Some disclaimers and miscellaneous comments: I AM NOT A MEDICAL DOCTOR. None of the following should be construed as medical advice, or actual pandemic data, or risk assessment for any person or group of people. I suppose I could have used the acronym IANAMD but I don’t find that nearly as entertaining as the acronym for I Am Not A Lawyer. However, IANAD (I am not a diplomat). You may not enjoy my attempts at humor, but IMHO, even serious topics sometimes need comic relief. First, what does it mean to spread out the cases and flatten the curve? This discussion is for those folks that think “If you’re gonna get it, you’re gonna get it. Might as well get it over with.” Fatalism: No matter what we do, if some percentage, say 70%, will become infected eventually, then why should we do anything?              It’s not that simple. The news provides us with a perfect ca...