Skip to main content

Things I Don't Understand


    Some uses for Classifications, Definitions, Refining definitions, and Re-purposing words.

On the one hand:

  1. Why do we drive on a parkway, and park on a driveway?
  2. Shouldn't hot water heaters be called cold water heaters? If the water is already hot, why heat it?
  3. Shouldn't there be another word that sounds like the word homonym but means something different or is spelled differently?
  4. See #3. Homonym apparently isn't precise enough to distinguish all possible cases. Therefore, we refine the concept with homophones, homographs, heteronyms, heterophones, heterographs, capitonyms. . . I'm not making these word up*. Even though I have difficulty remembering the distinctions among these more precise categories , I understand that for linguists, the ability to distinguish among various types of homonyms could be useful.
  5. For example, a capitonym changes its meaning or pronunciation when capitalized. For example furniture polish is not pronounced like Polish, the language. The bird turkey becomes the country Turkey when capitalized. Use a capitonym cautiously at the beginning of a sentence. Curiously, the word capitonym does not change its meaning or pronunciation when Capitalized.
  6. Also as an example, consider heteronyms AKA heterophones. Note: Synonyms have the same meaning but different spellings. Heteronyms have the same spelling but different meanings and pronunciations. For example wind in "I tried to wind the balloon string around my finger, but the wind was to strong."
  7. Heterographs have the same pronunciation, but different meanings and spellings. For example "to", "too", and "two".
(IIRC, the #1 was pointed out to me by Gallagher, #2 by George Carlin.)
Most folks don't have need for the above terminology, but the more precise refinements to categories of homonyms are useful to linguists.*https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homonym


On the other hand:


  • Agreeing on the definition of a word in context is essential to agreeing on a fact. Good definitions short circuit many semantic disputes. Axiomatic systems based on logic and precise definitions were designed by the Greek philosophers to aid in the pursuit of truth,

On the third hand:

  • Unlike philosophers, Politicians use pseudo-logic, prejudicial terminology and and misleading rhetoric in the pursuit of power. For example, in today's news, the Republicans plan to eliminate the word transgender by creating a strict binary definition of gender despite clear biological observations to the contrary. This is somewhat similar to the old political effort to re-define pi as a rational number or even repeal the law of gravity. However, the attempt to redefine will give their usual bathroom plank new life near mid-term elections when they need distractions from their plans for important issues.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Axioms, Definitions, and Alternate Facts.

Things I don't understand: Consider freedom, a word that is a rallying cry for all kinds of actions that might suppress rather than engender freedom. What is freedom? How is it defined? If it means what you think it does, would freedom ever need a modifier like relative or absolute? Does the word mean the same thing to everyone? Robert Frost said "You have freedom when you're easy in your harness." My interpretation of what Frost means is that if the constraints of society and the limitations imposed on you by your body, beliefs, abilities, etc., do not rest too heavily on you, then you feel free. Can we demand freedom for ourselves and yet deny it to our fellows? The hand you feel lightly on your shoulder may be an intolerable burden crushing your brother or sister. If you think there is an easy answer, then you're reading the wrong post. Defining words is not always easy. If a definition is intended to inform someone, then that definition must ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Tariffs Explained by the Shirt Off Your Back

Who Pays for Tariffs Explained by the Shirt Off Your Back.   Whether you are a fan of tariffs or not, it could be useful to discuss how they influence the price you pay for some simple item, like for instance, an inexpensive polo shirt. First, we need to know something about calculating retail prices. If you don’t give a damn about calculating retail prices, skip the next four paragraphs*. *Retailers usually determine the retail price of something they sell in terms of the markup , which is the amount added to their cost for the item. That markup is usually expressed as a percentage, and a common markup for items such as polo shirts is 40%. However, the base for that percentage markup should NOT be the cost of the item. Rather, it is almost always the selling price. Here’s why: *Suppose a seller’s cost for a package of underwear is $6.00 and he bases his 40% markup on his $6.00 cost. Calculating 40% of $6.00 produces 40% X $6.00 = $2.40. Add the $2.40 to $6.00: $2.40...
Post a Comment
Read more